With the sun out longer in the evening, we feel obliged to enjoy more than just one drink after dinner. In that spirit, we have two great bourbons for the club. We here at PlumpJack have been working more with Sazerac (more on that later in the year) and we started out with a private barrel pick of the venerable Buffalo Trace Bourbon. Our second selection is Old Fitzgerald’s 7 Year Bottled in Bond. Old Fitz is best known for their decanter series which are older, more allocated, offerings. Additionally, they have other more entry level focused offerings, but this marks their first foray into a mid-tier offering. Cheers to double the enjoyment!

Cheers!

Will Popko

Spirits Buyer


 

Buffalo Trace Bourbon PlumpJack Private Barrel & Old Fitzgerald 7 Year Bottled in Bond Bourbon

Location: Kentucky

Buffalo Trace Distillery, located in Frankfort, traces its roots to the late 1700s, when settlers began distilling whiskey near an ancient buffalo migration route that crossed the Kentucky River. In 1870, bourbon pioneer E. H. Taylor Jr. purchased and modernized the distillery, introducing innovations that helped establish Kentucky bourbon's reputation for quality. Later, under the leadership of George T. Stagg, the distillery grew into one of the region's most important whiskey producers. Renamed Buffalo Trace in 1999, the distillery is now recognized as one of the oldest continuously operating bourbon distilleries in America and produces some of the industry's most celebrated brands, including Buffalo Trace, Blanton's, Eagle Rare, and Pappy Van Winkle.

Old Fitzgerald is one of Kentucky's classic wheated bourbons, first created in 1870 by John E. Fitzgerald. Unlike many bourbons that use rye in the mash bill, Old Fitzgerald uses wheat, giving it a softer, smoother, and slightly sweeter flavor profile. It later became closely associated with Pappy Van Winkle and the legendary Stitzel-Weller Distillery, helping establish the reputation of wheated bourbon. Today, Old Fitzgerald is produced by Heaven Hill Distillery and is best known for its highly sought-after Bottled-in-Bond decanter releases, which have become favorites among bourbon collectors and enthusiasts.

Price: $32.99 | $69.99

Proof: 90 | 100

Tasting Notes:

Nose:

BT: vanilla, caramel, dark fruit

Old Fitz: toffee, oak, baking spices


Palate: 

BT: butterscotch, chocolate, oak

Old Fitz: sweet wheat, dried fruit


Finish:

BT: warm oak, mild spice

Old Fitz: honey, sweet spice

Mashbill: 

BT: Mashbill #1

Old Fitz: 68% Corn 20% Wheat 12% Malted Barley

More stories

Red Rogues Q2 2026: Fielder's Choice

Chances are you’ve seen, read or heard the term “field blend” in relation to wine. On one level, its meaning isn't super difficult to parse: a fiel...